LE Statements Part 3, A Fresh Look with Fresh Thoughts
If you missed part one and two please click here for part 1 and click here for part two.
From day one this is what LE has said, and in the order they said it in. I am using the Morning Sentinel for these statements. (Note: Some statements are in quotes and some are not- this is the way there were in the article) In hopes to shorten the article, I am only using the last names of the person making the statement. When two or more LE officials make a comment in the same article, I will use italics to separate them. Here is a short list of LE officials that have made statements; Police Chief Joseph Massey, Department of Public Safety Spokesman Steve McCausland, Waterville Deputy Police Chief Charles Rumsey, Lt. Kevin Adam of the Warden Service and Lt. Christopher Coleman who is the commander of the state police major crimes unit.
Feb 1st “Ayla’s Case Puts Police Spokesman in Spotlight” “You’ve characterized it that way, Nancy — we haven’t,” McCausland said, responding to Grace’s questions about blood, some of which belonged to Ayla, that investigators found in the home’s basement. McCausland wants to say just enough to keep the girl’s disappearance front and center in people’s minds without giving up details that police believe could hinder investigators’ efforts. “We’ve asked for help consistently from day one,” McCausland said in an interview later Tuesday. “We’ve done our best to keep the public informed because we are going to need their help to find Ayla. We are going under the premise that little Ayla was there that night,” McCausland told Grace at one point. “We’ve talked to Justin on a number of occasions,” McCausland told Grace. “When we’ve called him, he’s talked to us, and we hope that dialogue continues.” When asked about the WCVB report he said, “If you let it just stand, other stations are going to pick it up,” McCausland said. In fact, a local Channel 8 affiliate in Portland ran the report verbatim on its website, so “it was incumbent on us to make sure the public understood what our position is.” McCausland said the national media attention has had little impact how he and investigators go about their business. “It’s a few new faces, but otherwise, there really is no difference,” he said. “We obviously need a break in this case to locate this little girl,” McCausland said. “That’s going to come from information that’s given to us. It takes one call to break this case wide open.”
Feb 3rd “Divers Find No New Clues in Search for Ayla Reynolds” The dives into the Kennebec River, which was previously searched Jan. 11, and a stream that flows through the city yielded a backpack and a knife, neither of which is connected to Ayla Reynolds’ disappearance, Department of Public Safety spokesman Steve McCausland said. “We need that break. We need that information,” Waterville police Chief Joseph Massey said at a news conference. “The reward is out there, and we hope someone is going to give us that information for that break we need.” “I’ll be candid,” McCausland said. “It’s been 48 days and our concern grows every day, but we remain hopeful that we’ll find Ayla.”
Feb 4th “Divers Return to Ayla Search” The items they found were unrelated to the case, Adam said. “There’s nothing we feel (that) can be attributed to her right now.” Adam said last month’s searches were incomplete. Divers had considered returning earlier, but poor weather prevented it. “Once we search these areas, there will be more areas,” he said. McCausland said that the teams were “looking for clues to where she might be.” He said investigators are receiving fewer tips from the public than they were in the first weeks after the toddler disappeared. He prefaced all remarks by saying he wouldn’t disclose any investigative details about the case, but he confirmed that police have recently been in contact with the three adults; Justin, Courtney and Elisha. When asked if they were cooperating with the investigation, McCausland stopped short of a direct answer. “There has been contact, and we hope that contact will continue.” He added that police still believe Justin, Elisha and Courtney know more about Ayla’s disappearance than they’re sharing. “We have grave doubts that an abduction ever took place there.” He also confirmed that Ayla’s paternal grandmother, Phoebe, was not in the home the night before the toddler was reported missing. He wouldn’t say where she was, but said investigators confirmed she was at a different location. –Adam & McCausland
Feb 14th “Lawyer, Ayla’s Aunt, grandmother telling the truth” In a side note on this article the Moring Sentinel reports: State police won’t comment on website claims: Citing anonymous sources at the MSP, Ayla’s maternal family released a statement Monday that the child’s father, Justin, failed a police polygraph test, bought life insurance on the child after taking custody of her and sought termination of child support payments after he had custody of her. The statement was released on the website www.aylareynolds.com, which is run by Trista’s step-father Jeff. McCausland said Monday that he was aware of the Reynolds’ statement, but wouldn’t offer new information on the investigation. –anonymous sources & McCausland
Feb 16th “Grandfather, Police Challenge Ayla’s Dad” McCausland said investigators continue to work around the clock on the case. He said the number of tips from the public has exceeded 900. “We continue with as much energy and determination as when we began two months ago,” “At this point we would have liked to have had more answers, but that has not stopped the resolve to get those answers.” “We continue to encourage the immediate family to keep Ayla in the headlines and to talk about her,” “One side is doing that, and the other side is not.” -McCausland
March 11th “Father, Friends say it’s possible; cops say no way” On the same day police announced their belief that a kidnapping was implausible, they also announced that blood had been discovered during the investigation of 29 Violette Ave. Later, McCausland said some of the samples were Ayla’s blood, and the lab is analyzing other samples. He added the amount of blood attributed to Ayla was more than a small cut would produce. He said the decision by investigators to release the information was responsible. “We felt it was important that the public understand some specifics of the investigation. We felt it was important that the public understand the magnitude of this investigation and that some of the blood was Ayla’s.” He wouldn’t comment on whether more samples have been attributed to Ayla, but said investigators have made progress. “It’s a positive sign that the forensic work done by a committed team at the State Police Crime Laboratory is giving investigators new information almost on a daily basis, without getting into specifics.” –McCausland
Mar 17th “Search for Ayla Reynolds Hits 3-Month Mark” McCausland says investigators have received more than 970 leads, and detectives continue to conduct interviews. He says the crime lab is providing new evidence almost daily. -McCausland
Mar 20th “Police Decline to Comment on Blogs Claim in Ayla’s Case” “We were told by the lead investigators that (the blood) was ‘more than a cupful,’” according to the (Maternal Family) site. McCausland said Monday he has reviewed the blog but wouldn’t comment on its contents. “Any specifics that might be mentioned are investigative details that we’re not going to get into.” He said investigators are not losing steam as the case enters its fourth month. “The work continues, the resolve remains and progress is being made.” Although he wouldn’t comment on the specifics of the blog, He said the site serves a purpose. “It’s another way of utilizing the Internet to keep Ayla’s name in the forefront, and that is positive and helpful.” –McCausland
Mar 24th “During Today’s Ayla Reynolds Search, a 2004 Body Discovered” McCausland said investigators have received 988 tips in the Ayla Reynolds case, which is in its fourth month. He added that state police, Waterville police and the warden service have spent more than $100,000 in overtime related to finding Ayla. “That gives you an idea of the commitment that has taken place over the past three months, at least financially.” He also said that communication with the three adults who were in the home the night before Ayla was reported missing has “basically stopped.” Those adults are Justin, Courtney, and Elisha. “As I have stated all along, we believe those three individuals inside that home that night know things that they haven’t told us, and that is frustrating,” “But we continue on, we continue to make progress and the work will not stop.” Asked why communication has stopped, He said, “I guess you’ll have to ask them why the communication has stopped.” Unseasonably warm weather this winter and spring and the early disappearance of the winter’s snow enabled about 100 searchers, including members of the MWS, MSP, the Kennebec County Emergency Management Agency and local fire departments, volunteers with the Maine Association of Search and Rescue and cadaver dogs to search Saturday, said Adam. “Typically we wouldn’t be able to search in March this early,” “It’s great searching conditions out there. It’s mostly dry. There are no leaves, so you can see a long way. Good scenting conditions (for the dogs) – it’s not real hot, not real cold.” The search areas included parts of Waterville, Oakland, Sidney, Norridgewock and Fairfield. He said searches in Waterville were done to retrace areas that weren’t thoroughly investigated in December; shortly after Ayla was reported missing from her home on Violette Avenue. In Oakland, the search of First Park, an industrial park off Kennedy Memorial Drive, was meant to expand the areas that have been covered. Searches in other towns were in isolated areas based on higher-priority tips received by state police. Adam said more ground searches are planned for the coming weeks, as well as water searches by dive teams. McCausland also encouraged landowners in Kennebec County and the surrounding area to search their property for any signs of the missing girl, who turns 2 on April 4. “If they’re in the backyards, or back 40 … and they think they see something that might have some connection to this case, we obviously want to hear from them, and it doesn’t take much to break this case wide open.” He said the invitation extends to all Maine residents, “But obviously Kennebec County is a pretty wide swath from Waterville.” –McCausland & Adam
Mar 28th “Police, Lawyer for Ayla’s Family Differ on Communication Issue” McCausland agreed that investigators have few questions for the immediate family, but contends the paternal family has asked few questions of them. “Communication is a two-way street,” “If your daughter, granddaughter, niece was missing, wouldn’t you occasionally call police to ask for the status of the case? Put yourself in those shoes.” He added, “I will say (the communication issue) is not the case with Ayla’s mother and her relatives in greater Portland.” –McCausland
Mar 29th “Missing Toddler’s Mom Wants Answers” Investigators continue to work on the case every day, Coleman said. “This case remains very active,” “We’re still getting results back from the MSP crime lab. We’re working as hard as we can on it. We’re hoping we get that one lead that helps to break the case wide open.” -Coleman
I started this new page with a new outlook!! I want to let everyone know that it is no longer ok to bash or attack other commentators. The admins are capable of rectifying attacks upon ourselves but individual commentators do not have that luxury. . With this in mind, we have decided to impose a process that we will try to follow going forward to eliminate the stress and heartache of personal attacks by anyone on anyone. I do apologize for those that disagree with this process but we do feel it best to keep the focus on Ayla!
1st instance- The uncalled for name calling will be edited out and a warning posted.
2nd instance- The entire comment will be deleted.
3rd instance- If it still continues after steps one and two, we will send the offending IP to the blocked list.
I am sorry it has come to this for the time being but we do feel that it is the best way to keep Ayla the center of Aylas blog. If a comment is posted when no admin is present, please do not comment directly as your reply may be effected when an admin is present and modifies the offending comment. Thank you for you cooperation in this matter. And prayers to Ayla and her family.
United for Ayla






PB, I apologize for not including pictures with this post. I will try again tomorrow to get the added. I want to thank you again for bringing the comment ““We continue to encourage the immediate family to keep Ayla in the headlines and to talk about her,” “One side is doing that, and the other side is not.” -McCausland” to the forefront. We lost track of that the past few days, but I will do my best to prevent Ayla from becoming the second story on her own blog. Ayla must stay at the forefront in the media and on her blog.
Good Job John! I think the new outlook is a good way to get back on track! I think that I am going to go back and re-read these articles and see if anything new or forgotten pops out in a different light!
You are a great friend and supporter for Ayla Purple. Thank you so much for all you have done for Ayla.
I agree PB and John. Let’s get back to Ayla.
Thank you PB for all your hard work and for being a great supporter for Ayla.
Hoping the next press conference will be about arrests made in this case.
We all notice that. The paternal family seems to be moving on, and not allowing the name Ayla to be mentioned, at least in public. BUT, for McCausalnd to say that is huge. Very telling. MSP spokesman has confirmed our fears! Our fear of her being a COLD CASE and forgotten.
Ayla is NOT a cold case nor will she ever be forgotten !!!!
I agree Chicky! But, when MSP spokesman says the family is not interested in keeping her in the news, it is crazy and very telling. This is a sad day for Ayla, and she deserves Justice now more than ever.
Suz, it is unfortunate but Since April 19th, Justin has not spoken Aylas name publically. It is more of the same that we have come to expect from the father of a missing child. This statement from Feb is going to remain true until Justin and his family decide it is time to speak for Ayla.
I agree Chichky, McCauslands statement was from Feb 16th and then it was just the paternal family that was not speaking. The MSP silence of late is, according to LE Anon, a good thing meaning that MSP has the evidence they need and are simply waiting for testing to be completed, to do a few more searches, or tie some of the lose ends together before proceeding. I do not believe either that Ayla will become a cold case.
Thanks John: I wish we could hear something
from Anon Retired LE. He is great for keeping
this case on a positive track.
I don’t think it’s a cold case either. I think we will see lots of action after the elections.
I get the chills up my spine….literally….when I hear of Ayla being mentioned as a Cold Case. We keep hope in our hearts that she will be found. The cold hearted people involved in Ayla “being disappeared” need to speak up about whatever they know and stop this fiasco. We need laws….nationally …to prevent people from withoholding information in any missing person cases. There are too many missin g persons in this country, too many of them children.
Well said Glenda!
ITA Glenda. It has to start with changing the laws so that the missing child has equal rights under the law. As it is right now, I do not feel that they do.
ITA. Laws need to change when it comes to
missing persons.
I totally agree , children are treated as mere objects that belong to their parents. They are possessions that parents settle in divorce settlement.
““We continue to encourage the immediate family to keep Ayla in the headlines and to talk about HER,”
I don’t know about you guys, but I have heard a lot of talk about Justin. A lot of talk about Phoebe and her gun. Courtney and her smile. Elisha and her child.
Not so much talk about Ayla lately—FROM EITHER SIDE.
When was that quote dated, the one from McCausland? TIA
Are my comments no longer being posted here?
JW, You have not been blocked or anything. When a comment comes in from a new IP it automatically sent to moderation. I did not get on until now to approve it. To answer your question about the date McCausland made the comment, it was Feb 16th.
Thanks John!
Please do not thank me. It has always been about Ayla and it is something that we got sidetracked from. I just hope that we can continue on with discussions pertaining to Ayla.
We will!
ITA with you!!
Was Trista or any of her family members interviewed at the bike run ?
Yes Chicky, I do know that I saw Trista doing an interview with a blond haired female reporter. There are pics of this on the Aylas Angel FB page which I can ask to post here but I don’t think it is needed. I just don’t know if it was radio or television or which station or channel. Maybe some of the others who attended will know that information.
I noticed the same thing John. I wondered why we did not see her on any of the news stations… then I thought!! Maybe it was live radio that was broadcasting real time!! I only saw Trista with the mic from far away and between other people, so I did not even notice if there was a camera – I just assumed.
So to sumise what has been stated in this post about communication:
February 4th -16th: Something happened between those dates where communication between the paternal side and LE was wavering.
March 24th: A definate stance from LE that communication has stopped from the paternal side
March 26th: A public statement from LE that states that the maternal side communicates to LE as a family should in a case like this. And a definate statement that the paternal family is not doing the norm in cases like this.
So the big question is: what was it that LE asked them or tell them in Feb/March that made them run away!!??
Exactly. I’m sure it’s much more than the blood evidence that more than a small cut would produce.
That is definately the big question in regards to this exchange of words. Recall that the family stated communications waas two way street and if LE was not going to answer questions pertaining to the case the paternal family would not ask questions. But to me it is normal for LE not to answer investigative questions and abnormal for a family not to answer questions concerning a missing family member.
Ruby, one thing that happened between those dates was the grand jury.
I was thinking the same thing CG.
Justwondering ** So, yes we have heard from Trista very recently. I thought it was radio and I should have tuned in. I wish there had been a television station there.
Justin has the opportunity now to interview with two TV stations under HIS terms but as of yet he has not returned calls, texts, nor has he responded to the notice that was posted here as well as other places on the web that folks have been kind enough to share.
I agree, I have seen this message posted on several websites and several blogs. The two most notible absentee sites to post the offer though is TLLOM. If Angela truely wanted to set up an interview for JD, why have they not posted the offer you mentioned. I have seen it on three facebook pages and here as well. I hope it gets posted on TLLOM and JD takes the televion news people up on thier offer. Ayla needs answers to many questions.
Well, angela claims it is what justin wants, so if they are both honest people we should be hearing of an interview soon.
Honest? Angela? Justin? We will see, Chicky, but I wont be holding my breath!
Nor I Ldybg.
Like my name, I am JUSTWONDERING, was Trista interviewed more recently than June?
Sept 1 and I believe it was radio. I unfortunately missed it and have not found a copy on youtube. I witnessed the interview with my own eyes though. As you say I am a liar, which I took offense to previously, you will obviously not believe my eyes as validation for this comment. If that is the case, I suggest you ask others that were at the Ride for Ayla and ask them.
She was interviewed. And I think there is a photo or 2 floating around on FB.
PB had an article not long ao about children who were murdered by one of their parents. It would be interesting to look at each case and compare the behaviour of the maternal and paternal side of the child, to the behaviour of Ayla’s maternal and paternal family members. It would also be interesting to compare the behaviour of the guilty parent with that of the non guilty parent.
I saw the photos Ruby. I just could not tell which station or channel it was conducting the interview. I can not zoom in from this terminal to see if there are any indicators. But I did see her being interviewed from a distance.
good idea mm
Who is the ORIGINAL author of that comment?
Which comment?
The one telling Justin about interviews. Couldn’t they have found a way to contact him directly? It seems like they wanted to get the blogoverse involved unnecessarily.
If no one is worried about showing wheather justin/angela are sincere in their desire
to speak out for Ayla via live media I don’t see what the problem is.
It’s also not up to you to just book people for interviews. I guess I have to watch my back so that I don’t end up being interviewed on Good Morning America tomorrow.
I think Justin and Trista both have enough name recognition to be able to set up their own awareness events and press for their own child.
I love your sentiments and your drive for Ayla, but this is over the line. It’s over the top and disrespectful to me and everyone else who may fall victim to you forcing us into the press.
maybe you still don’t understand, I do not BOOK interviews,
Justwondering, I am confused by what you mean when you say Chicky is disrespectful to you for trying to set up interview possibilities for Justin. How does that disrespect you? Are you Justin? Or did I misunderstand what you were saying was disrespectful to you?
The two TV stations do in fact want interviews. Justin has refused in the past apparently because restrictions were placed that he did not agree with. The media is making it clear that any restrictions on an interview will only be ones that justin himself wishes to impose.
It was no trouble at all to inform media why justin has refused and for them to state that they Do want interviews according to justins guidlines.
Just to be clear, the reporters from the two news station DID NOT post the notice themselves.
I’m sorry, I think we have a misunderstanding.
I’m wondering who started posting the comment.
Who wrote it, and how does anyone know that
the info is true?
I have had dialogue with both reporters..
I posted it and I know that the info is true. Wheather or not the woman who answered his phone chose to give him the message or not no one knows other than her and justin.
Are you Justin’s agent or something? I’m confused as to how
someone he doesn’t even know can set up interviews for him?
Why are you stepping into that role? Have you set up any interviews for anyone else? JUST WONDERING, because that seems sort of weird to have a very biased person calling around on your behalf.
There’s something wrong with what you said.
Justin sets up his own interview if he so desires. I did not state that i would SET UP the interview. maybe you need to actually read the post and see that the info
was there .
Wheather you like it or not that’s up to you.
You do realize that that’s some sort of crime?
Who accepts the compensation?
What promises are you making to secure the interviews? I don’t need your inside secrets, just a general idea of how you sold the interviews.
Justwondering said:
“You do realize that that’s some sort of crime?
Who accepts the compensation?
What promises are you making to secure the interviews? I don’t need your inside secrets, just a general idea of how you sold the interviews.”
I believe Chicky already told you ad nauseam that she doesn’t setup or even attempt to setup interviews for Justin DiPietro. Why can’t you simply accept her answer? I don’t understand why you keep berating her about it? She hasn’t done anything illegal. Why don’t you criticize Angela Harry for posting regarding Justin participating in interviews? I am just curious.
Thank you RCO, very well stated. ITA that JW is simply trying to instigate Chicky and if it continues I will have no choice but to respond myself.
Justwondering, it’s not a crime to call someone and ask if that person would be willing to interview another person if the second person is willing and to notify the second person of the answer. That’s what Chicky seems to have done here. Asked a question and repeated the answer.
apparently he needs help getting an interview. according to one of his mumma bears no one will interview peaches on his terms. This Little Light of Maine for those who doubt that Justin has had this issue… Ben could tell you that I asked his advice on it months ago. in terms of how to present the queries to the media we were contacting. it’s a very real issue and their not taking Justin up on his request for interviews hurts Ayla’s chance at being found. And her chance for justice.
September 6 at 12:07pm via mobile
This Little Light of Maine. Justin and I have tried for MONTHS AND MONTHS to get different media oitlets to do an interview. They will not. I bet you’re thinking it’s because he’s stated that he refuses to answer questions about evidence, etc. Nope. Not the case. The letters specifically state that absolutely everything is on the table for discussion other than talkin *about* Trista, her family, their relationship. He won’t do it. And THAT is why no one sees Justin on a news network…..
What’s wrong with helping him get an interview? Obv, his network of ppl don’t have the ability to get it done.
Thank you for pointing this out Heartbroken. Hopefully JW will now understand it is no-one on this site trying to attack or make money of from this line of commenting. The comments were made by Angels and we are simply trying to help with what apparently is a dilemma for them to get done. We have made several friends in the media. Our friends will and have tried to contact Justin in this regard. Where is the interview?
Got another one!
Ayla Reynolds: Nancy 12/19/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Issues 12/19/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Issues 12/20/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Nancy 12/20/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Issues 12/21/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Nancy 12/21/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Nancy 12/28/11 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Issues 1/9/12 – YouTube
Ayla Reynolds: Issues 1/25/12 – YouTube
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIP…/19/ng.01.html
12/19/11
TRISTA REYNOLDS: A few weeks ago, Justin had given me a call and said that he was holding Ayla and they fell up, like, two or three little steps, and he fell on top of her and her arm was broken. And he waited over — almost 24 hours to bring her to the emergency room.
I want — I want reasons — I want to know reasons to why — why do you wait almost 24 hours to bring a child to — he himself told me she screamed bloody murder when they fell, so you wait almost 24 hours to go have her checked out?
REYNOLDS: No, when she started staying with Justin, she was actually sleeping in, like, a toddler bed.
REYNOLDS: Ayla knows how to open doors, but I also have taught Ayla that we don`t walk outside without Mommy or an older adult. And Ayla never once had ever tried getting outside, unless I was right there by her.
GRACE: I`m going to come back to Dr. Carter. But very quickly, Trista Reynolds is with us. This is Ayla`s mom. Trista, you went to court in secret just hours before Ayla goes missing, 20-month-old baby girl with a sling on her arm. Did you prevail? Did the judge suggest to you that you were going to get full custody?
REYNOLDS: I haven`t even gotten that far. All I have done is file the paperwork, and that was it. I haven`t seen a judge. I haven`t talked to a lawyer. I have done nothing but file…
GRACE: So you went all on your own without even a lawyer to help you, trying to get custody. Why, Trista, were you trying to get full custody?
REYNOLDS: Because her father has never had anything to do with her up until I needed to go and get a little bit of help for myself. And then when I left my daughter with my sister, that`s when he decided, You know what? I`m going to take Ayla.
And I want to put it out there that every time my daughter has gone with Justin, she would always come back with bruises on her or she had come back with a pulled muscle. And in the 18 months that I had had my daughter, not once did she ever end up missing, did she ever end up with a broken bone, did she ever miss a doctor`s appointment. And since she`s been with Justin, she has missed four appointments for shots. And this past Friday, she missed her bone specialist appointment.
GRACE: You know, yes — you know, Trista, another question. I want to follow-up on what Renee Rockwell just said. Who all was in the home, Trista? And have you talked to the father?
REYNOLDS: No, Justin and I have had no contact.
RONALD REYNOLDS, MISSING CHILD`S GRANDFATHER (via telephone): I said — I`m sorry, ma`am. I don`t know. Honestly, I don`t know. All I know is what was told what happened with her arm, and that she went to the doctors, got it checked out, and apparently, it was broken from the fall.
TIRSTA REYNOLDS, AYLA REYNOLDS` MOTHER (via telephone): No. I did not tell Justin that I was going to the court to file. Now, me and him had had the discussion within that week that he told me himself that he was going to file the custody papers against me. So I decided to go and file against him.
GRACE: All right. So he did not know, then? In your mind, he did not know that you had filed the papers?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: No, I wanted him not to know that I was filing –
GRACE: Why? Why didn`t you want him to know?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Why didn`t I want him to know?
GRACE: Right.
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Because he`s vindictive. He`s very verbally abusive towards me and anything that I say or do, he refuses to let me see my daughter, he`s refused to let me talk to her. I mean, he has never, like, once since he`s had her, since October 17th, had let me have her for one single day. So, I decided that it was time to do this the legal way and let a judge say who this child should be with. And my daughter does deserve to be with me. I`m the one who`s raised her for 18 months.
Trista, can you tell me, one of the callers asked why the dad had the baby to start with. I told them, as you heard, that you were briefly in rehab. You put yourself in rehab to get past some problems you had, but the night the baby goes missing, which is what I`m concerned, I don`t care what anybody did before that, where were you the night the baby goes missing, Trista?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: The night that my daughter went missing, I was at the Maine motel in South Portland.
GRACE: And you have fully cooperated with police, is that true?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Fully cooperated. And Nancy, there`s one thing I want to clear up with you.
GRACE: OK.
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Someone just said that — it was said that Ayla had her own bedroom at her father`s house. She does not have her own bedroom. She sleeps in the same room with her cousin, who is, I think, two months younger than her. So, if — so why wasn`t she taken? If my daughter went missing, why didn`t her cousin — you know, at least make a noise or scream or be taken as well.
GRACE: So you`re telling me that, Trista, that there would have been somebody else sleeping in the room with her?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Yes! Like, I`ve been to that house myself, and I have been in the bedroom to where Ayla sleeps, and she sleeps in the same exact room as Justin`s sister`s little girl.
GRACE: And how old is the little girl?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: I think she`s exactly — I think she`s like two months younger than Ayla.
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: OK, well, let me clear one thing up.
GRACE: OK.
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Justin and I have never been in a serious relationship, ever.
GRACE: OK. So that means that there was never any domestic abuse, because you never lived together?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: No. We`ve never lived together, we`ve never been together. We were just two mutual friends.
GRACE: I want to go right now — OK, hold on, I`m getting another question — OK, another caller has another question, Trista, about a bone specialist. Did the baby see a bone specialist when she broke her arm?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: Yes, we took her to Maine orthopedics, right in Portland.
GRACE: And what did they say?
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: They said that at first it seemed to be suspicious, and then they said the way that her arm was broken, it may not have been suspicious and it could have been accidental.
TIRSTA REYNOLDS: My daughter — I don`t see Ayla doing it either. And Ayla would never wander off unless there was someone with her.
Just wondering, the original comments originated from Angela stating that Justin has been refused interviews by the media. I have a few friends in media myself and they have all told me also that there was “No Way” media would turn down and interview with him unless there were restrictions that violate the rules of conduct for that media. My friends called when they saw the comments from Angela, no answers. I asked them to e-mail him. No responses. This seems to me that you are confronting the wrong person on this. If there is no interview to be done, confront Angela.
You say “I think Justin and Trista both have enough name recognition to be able to set up their own awareness events and press for their own child.”
You are correct they both have the name recognition, but when will the time be right for Justin to “set up his own awareness events and press for his child”.
So, if Justin does an interview, Ayla will be found?
I don’t understand the big deal. He has done interviews before. He’s not going to ay anything new. Wtf do people want?
And I have not been rude, but if someone lies then they are called a liar. It is a lie to say that Trista has pleaded for Ayla in every interview.
That’s not instigating, that’s pointing out an inaccurate statement before the blogoverse turns it into fact.
And I have not been rude, but if someone lies then they are called a liar. It is a lie to say that Trista has pleaded for Ayla in every interview.
JW, if you insist on calling me a liar, prove it with a link where Trista did an interview where she claimed her innocense and did not mention missing, loving, caring for, or wanting Ayla returned home. Show me the proof as you say, or I will consider this last comment of calling me a liar the last straw. If your intent is to instigate conversation from Ayla, you have done so. You have however instigated the wrong person. You have twisted the words again of the wrong person, and you have invoke the ire of the wrong person. I speak in regards to Ayla and you have left me defending my own physical and visual observations. That is not acceptible. You say you have not been rude, What is it then when you call someaone a liar without backing it up and that person was stating an opinion? You succeeded in your attempts. Provide me proof that Trista has not plead begged cried and yell at the top of her lungs for Ayla!!
You know what Just Wondering, I dont even want you to show me the proof. Simply cease the name calling and twisting of words by the commentators, stay on issues related to Aylas case, and we will be fine. In other words do not comment to me and I will not comment to you. That way there is no missunderstanding by anyone. Also, keep it level with the other commentators or you will go to moderation! I am done with this topic COMPLETELY!
I’ll add them as I find them!
http://video.today.msnbc.msn.com/tod…14327#45814327
Dec.29th2011 TR on Today Show
Q: What are police telling you?
TR: Uh, the same thing that I hear on the news. Um..but they, they’ll kind of call me now first before I hear it on the news, but it’s the same thing. That they’re still investigating, they’re still where we were 13 days ago.
Q: Ayla was with her father when she was last seen. He has not spoken publicly but he did release a statement through the police. Do you think that JD has anything to do with your daughters disappearance?
TR: I don’t know. Part of me feels yes and a part of me feels no. It’s just…
Q: Explain the part of you that feels yes?
TR: Just..you know, like, he says he’s not in hiding, but why won’t he come out? Why won’t he talk to me? Why..why is he staying away? You know, like, just, what is he so afraid of to not come out or to talk to me?
Q: We should mention that in a lot of these situations in the past, parents do come forward and go on television but it is every ones right not to do that. And in his statement he says “It is important that the people hear it from me personally that I have no idea what happened to Ayla and that I am not hiding. I have been in full cooperation with everyone in this effort, including not adding additional media hype.” Your response to that?
TR: I don’t got one. I’m still in shock with what he wrote, like what he put out in his statement.
Q: What really got my attention on this, Trista, last night, was that you and he have not spoken since your daughter disappeared. You’ve tried to call him..
TR: Mhmm.
Q: He has not responded to your calls..
TR: Uh-uh.
Q: Have you tried to get the police to act as intermediaries, create some sort of dialogue between you two?
TR: Yep. I’ve asked that question and they tell me that it’s between me and him. Like, it’s on me and him to contact one another.
Q: I would think, as a police officer investigating this, you’d want to see the parents interacting at least maybe to observe it. But they..
TR: Right.
Q: They’ve offered no opportunity for you to be in contact with your daughter’s father?
TR: None.
Q: Um, a little background on your relationship with Justin, according to you, you and Justin had an agreement that he would take care of Ayla while you were in rehab back in October.
TR: That’s right.
Q: Other reports suggest that CPS gave Justin temporary custody of Ayla. I don’t think you agree with that. But, after you got out of rehab, a month went by where you never saw Ayla, why?
TR: No, I had went like two and a half weeks without seeing her when I first got out of rehab, and then after, um, like the first week of November, I didn’t see her again until the 21st of November. And then after the 21st of November I did not see her again.
Q: Have you been critical of Justin’s parenting? Do you worry that she was not safe in his care?
TR: Yeah.
Q: For what reason?
TR: Just..you know, just for the reasons like he would never let me see her. I would call to talk to her and he’d get mad about it. I mean like, if I did see her and I would notice something on her like a bruise or just, something, he, instead of like, reacting in a calm manner he would lash out about it, or kind of like, go into defense.
Q: I have to ask you at the end here. You filed for sole custody of Ayla the day before she disappeared, did you have anything to do with her disappearance? Or did you send anyone up to that house to take your baby back?
TR: No. And I didn’t file for sole custody. All I filed for was parental rights and responsibilities. That’s it. It wasn’t sole custody.
Q: If you could speak to Justin right now what would you say to him?
TR: Just come talk to me. Like, just talk to me. You know, like, he’s the only one that can answer some of my questions. You know, like, we have a daughter that is missing. We used to be able to get along all the time. Just talk to me. That’s all I want, just..he was the last one to see her alive. Like, just talk to me. That’s all I want. Just talk to me.
None of us knows the totality of what Trista has said in interviews (or Justin, or anyone else in this case) and focusing too intently on this point misses the big picture because:
* Print journalists don’t typically (can’t reasonably) print every word spoken.
* The interviewer typically chooses the interview focus, the interview (save politicians maybe) responds to the questions asked.
* TV interviews are sometimes live, sometimes recorded. Some have been edited. What the public sees may be all or only part of what was said.
* Someone who is not sophisticated or familiar with the milieu will easily go with the flow rather than promote their own agenda when thrust into the media spotlight.
* Interviews happen in context and some things are understood between interviewer and interviewee. On Nancy Grace, for example, Nancy Grace herself put out info about calling the tipline in some of the interviews. Trista would not need to ask people to call with tips so Trista would not likely repeat the request.
* It’s missing the forest for the trees to focus on whether Trista explicitly reached someone to return Ayla when police have said there was no kidnapping.
Thank you CG Very well stated and very clearly too. An excellent observation on your part.
As far as we know from from Justin’s few words regarding Ayla’s disappearance, he knows, or let’s say assumes, that Ayla is with people who care for her. Also, he feels that Ayla has adjusted to her new surroundings and no doubt she thinks it’s just another address. So can we assume that Justin has no fears for her?
Phoebe said, “Nothing happened to Ayla except she was taken.” Okay. Obviously Phoebe also knows that Ayla is safe. if she thought it was a stranger abduction, wouldn’t she be concerned if Ayla was in safe hands?
As far as Elisha has expressed anything, she also seems to hold no worries about Ayla’s safety. Although Elisha did turn up at one of the events for Ayla, she has never said she was afraid for Ayla’s safety.
Has Heidi asked for Ayla to be brought back to her famiy because she is afraid for Ayla’s safety? I know she wants Ayla returned for Justin’s sake to alleviate the unfounded suspicions rattling around Peachy, but I can’t recall Justin’s in-house lawyer expressing any fears about Ayla’s well being in the hands of her abductor.
Ditto for Angela. She wants Ayla returned for for the health and safety of the DiPietros.
Courtney has made zip comments to the press about the missing child whom she professed to love like her own. Has she expressed any fears on Face Book or My Space concerning her concerns for Ayla’s safety? I did hear that she put up pictures of Ayla in between her wedding-gift requirements.
Lance is hard to pin down. He hasn’t really expressed concerns for Ayla as he has always been rather busy with hammering physically or verbally anyone whom he considers dissing his people…those people who lost Ayla. However, he did plan a vigil for Ayla which looked to some like a funeral. And lately he has been verbally wishing death and destruction upon Trista and her family and supporters.
Except for Lance, then, none of the DiPietros have bad-mouthed anyone, stranger or aquaintence; nor have they claimed any knowledge of the actual culprits involved in Ayla’s disappearance. (I’m not talking about online defenders of Justin of the anonymous persuasion.)
What does their lack of expressed public worry about Ayla, coupled with professed lack of knowledge about how she went missing and where she is, now, tell us about the beliefs of the DiPietros and their immediate crew? Remember Justin said the truth is the truth and “it will all come out.” and “Now is not the time.”
1.)They know someone in the Reynolds family has Ayla, but not where. LE won’t assist them in tracking Jessica’s or the Fortiers’ hiding place as LE doesn’t believe Ayla was abducted. .
2.) Theyare in cahoots with some well meaning DiPietro relation or friend and conspired with the abductor to take Ayla to save her from Trista.
3.) They know a DiPietro relation has Ayla, and they know where, but they don’t want to implicate this do-gooder by going to get Ayla and exposing the well-meaning person to criminal charges..
4.) They know a stranger abducted Ayla, but they feel that the kidnapper wanted a baby and will treat Ayla well until the DiPietros can find her.
5.) They know a stranger abducted Ayla. Hey! They don’t care. Good riddance to a big problem. Good luck to you!
6.) They know Ayla is dead from some kind of neglect, accident or understandable “loosing it”.One or more in the family or among friends know where Ayla is located.
I’m sure I’ve missed some other explanations of why the DiPietros express no worried about Ayla’s health and welfafre because all of them profess to believe she is alive and “out there”.
Great post Penny. I do agree with everything you say and maybe one more reason they are silent, They know Ayla is gone and are more concerned with covering each other than admitting any wrong doing.
John, I personally find it quite telling that Justin DiPietro has remained silent since the media release regarding Ayla’s blood being discovered in the basement of Phoebe DiPietro’s home. It is entirely unacceptable that instead of Ayla’s own father explaining how and why the blood Ayla’s blood was there, the public has to hear secondhand information–via the internet–from people, (Heidi, and Bob Vear), who are not even family members of Ayla. Has there been even one member of Ayla’s paternal family who has publicly spoken regarding the blood? Explain this–if it isn’t true that more than a cup of Ayla’s blood was discovered in Phoebe DiPietro’s home, why hasn’t Justin himself publicly disputed it? Why doesn’t the homeowner, Phoebe DiPietro, come forward and explain how her gradndaughter, Ayla’s blood ended up in the basement of her house? I was just reading here while I had a chance and decided to comment. Goodnight!
The only person I have heard from the paternal family to comment on that is Phoebe’s sister Selena (who says it was only a few drops from Phoebe cutting her foot, woops, I mean Ayla cutting her foot , the story changes so who knows?). She does not have first hand knowledge, only what she has been told by her family. She admits to not having close contact until recently and she doesn’t ask them questions.
adding to jds few words…..”he wishes the police could offer immunity to the kidnapper so Ayla can be returned.”
This statement seems to indicate that Justin knows who has Ayla (if she was abducted or handed over to someone willingly, which would be most likely). Why else would he wish for immunity for someone who came into his home and took his daughter? If a stranger came into the home and took Ayla, a loving, rational parent would come unglued and the LAST thing they would wish for would be immunity for the perpetrator…..IMO
Great post Penny, hopefully Justin will answer you as to what is happening with his daughter.
“Loosing” it? I’ve been reading on the Net too much! I do know the difference between “loose” and “lose”. I meant “losing” it. Although someone may have “unloosed” something on Ayla like normal restraint.
Another Great Post Penny!
Thanks, Heart, and ya’ll. I post sincerely wanting to know why the DiPietros do not seem worried…have never seemed worried…about Ayla. There has to be a reasonable explanation. The respnse of “Everybody worries (grieves) in his/her own way.” does not cut it. To publicly show little concern is not human. To not take advantage of ways to keep her name in the public’s awareness is not normal. To say that Ayla has enough media exposure without Justin himself adding to it is not fatherly.
That is not to say that I know for sure Justin and his family are not wracked with worry behind closed doors.
I am sure Justin, if given a sporting chance to speak without having to bash anybody, will set the record straight.
That chance IS on the table right now.
I would only change one word in the comment Penny. The last 5 words should be Could set the record straight. I say could because on april 19th he told a television crew that he had no comment and has not spoken out publically since that day for Ayla. He has another opportunity now to step up and answer the questions that Ayla deserves and he once again has failed to respond. I say could because he has made it clear that Aylas story will not be told by him. I believe it will be MSP and the AG who tells Aylas story and I hope that whoever is responsible is held accountable soon.
Truly he has had the opportunity all along to speak under the conditions that angela says he wants, it has just been made perfectly clear so that there are no misunderstandings. You are correct John, that there has been no response from him.
Without speaking to them personally, or knowing how they tend to react to stressful situations, how can you conclude that the DiPietros are not worried?
JUST WONDERING, because there are times when Trista doesn’t even seem worried, yet those quotes and interviews are not being discussed here.
She quotes and interviews all the time compared to the 2 times, last time back in April, that Justin did. She tries to look brave and you take it as unworried because you have never been in her shoes. You have never received that call from LE. Justin never called her with the news that Ayla was gone. To me the fact that he did not call her and work with her at the onset of this is unforgivable. That action is the action of a real screwball jerk IMO. Then after LE tells her he didn’t work with her. Then his GF posts on Facebook, why is Trista calling wanting to talk to him all the time. Why does he need to talk to her at all. I saw that post, and it was to that effect.
And I would add that her strength is said to be uncaring, her crying is said to be crocodile tears. This is a double standard that has been exploited on another site over and over and yet Trista still puts herself in the line of fire. Why would she do that? FOR AYLA!!!
Is it possible that Justin is really strong as well?
If Trista’s worry is masked as strength, maybe Justin’s is as well?
Have you ever been in Justin’s shoes?
JUST WONDERING, because what you said goes both ways.
I have not been in Justins shoes nor he in mine. That part does go both ways. As for Tristas emotions being torn apart like Justins, it is not IMO a double standard. Trista has gone the full scope of emotions, in public, and been torn apart for it regardless of the emotions displayed. Justin has shown one emotion, and that is none. He has no comments FOR Ayla, no public pleas, and no active public support, in the form of awareness events, that I have seen. That part is no comparison.
Just Wondering. I respectfully disagree. Every interview she has done,she has begged for Ayla to return. Every event there is, Trista is there passing out posters, pins, pens, cards, hats, shirts, and talking to anyone that will talk with her. The latest event being Sept 1 in Portland, where she did do an interview, and where was the paternal family. I hope you understand why we dont talk about something that really does not exist in my eyes.
Johm P—a simple review of Trista’s interviews proves your statement to be made up. That is simply not true.
Nothing against you, I would just hate for your inaccurate comment to become “fact” here in the blogoverse.
I do not belive Johns statements to be untrue. if anyone questions it then they can look up ALL the interviews themsleves and form their own opinions.
Hard to tell anything about justin in interviews as there are so few.
Nice, Chicky. What you believe is not fact. YOU look up the interviews and then come back and see how both you and Johm P. are now lying.
What is wrong with a little fact-checking? You are attacking me, but that is all I am doing. Balancing things is always a great thing when everyone in the world is out of control I always seek balance. I do yoga too.
The word I used was , “opinion”.
The word you need to become acquainted with is “FACT”.
I deal with opinions AND facts.
Now, I have no interest in continuing this conversation
as you are purposly being rude and I do not generally
engage. I tolerate easily others opinions but have no interest
testy dialogue.
I think your dialogue was just as testy. It’s okay, because you have proven yourself to be a true friend of Ayla. That makes you a friend of me, whether you like it or not! <3 you, have a good night!
Just wondering, I hope you read the comments at the bottom of the post. To start calling names of the commentators on the site is not the desired comments on this site. Our responses were respectful and if you insist on calling Chicky and myself liars for making a comment that I witnessed with my own eyes is strike one. Perpetuating that is tantamount to instigation arguements taking away from discussions pertaining to Ayla. I do not mind questioning, I do take offense to being called a liar for what I witnessed and the opinions I formed.
I get that Trista was on the radio. If so, they must have a tape of it and maybe it could be put on youtube or something. I miss Jeff and Trista. Yet, I know that they can expose themselves just so much.
Who cares if you do Yoga???? Everyone needs to focus on JUSTICE FOR AYLA REYNOLDS!!!! This blog is not for defending Justin’s little man complex. He needs to get his A… out there and defend himself. Bottom line is he was not at the bike run, he was not at Aylas Birthday party. But, he can go to Portland for anything else. Anything but speaking out for his daughter. He’s acting like a sperm donor more than a committed father. Trista needs no defending, her actions speak loud enough. She is still working with a major Missing Person agency. Why doesn’t Justin pay for a private detective, instead of a defense lawyer. Same goes for Phoebe and Elisha, why do they need to spend money on defines lawyers for the past 6 or 7 months, instead of a good PI????
What the heck is wrong with you?
You come on full blast, speaking in broken English like a Ukranian mobster.
lol
I’ll be happy to discuss with you Sue but calm down please? My head hurts already and my mantras are not helping this time. I cannot deal with this and you too, so please stoppit.
I’m Irish, but you are plain crazy! Just wondering, who cares where people are from now??? You sound racist. You need to keep the focus on JUSTICE FOR AYLA and off me.
DEFENSE LAWYERS FOR THE DiPietros!! private ones at that. I thought they were innocent??? Private Investigators to get their baby back I could understand, but Private Defense Lawyers from the beginning???
Again, what are you talking about Suzie?
Just wondering, what is your reading level??? Oh yea, Ayla may not get the chance to go to school. Keep your focus on Ayla and off of other bloggers. Why you even care where some stranger is from, is beyond me. You need to start caring more about Ayla and less about Irish people from the outskirts of Dublin. I could give a hoot about where you are from, but I know where you’re going. And, knock off all the LOL’s, it is extremely inappropriate in a blog about finding Justice for a missing baby named Ayla.
No one corrected you when you were just talking about Ashley P and threatening to leave this blog. That had nothing to do with AYLA, AYLA, AYLA.
Please stop. This is not about you or me Suz. If my questions
make you upset, don’t answer them! Sorry for the inconvenience!
Suz it seems they got them about the time that 1. LE said there was foul play and 2. grand jury summonses went out to Elisha, Phoebe, and Courtney. Not sure which came first, summons or lawyer, but it does make sense to consult a criminal lawyer when you receive a summons to testify before a grand jury. As for Justin, his not getting a summons when everyone else did was a big clue who police might think committed a crime so it makes since he got a lawyer too. If you were entirely innocent but found yourself in these circumstances, wouldn’t you want expert advice?
You are right CG, there is nothing sinister in itself that members of DiPietro family engaged the services of a criminal defense attorney(s) when they are (among) the subjects of a criminal investigation. They would be crazy not to. Guilty or innocent, they have the same rights to due process as anyone and hiring a lawyer to help protect one’s rights is standard.
We cannot protect the rights of the innocent without also protecting the rights of the guilty. That’s not saying that one or more of the DiPietro’s are guilty, that’s just a comment on how our criminal justice system works.
I agree with you on how your read into the issue of who was summonsed and who wasn’t, if that is indeed what happened. The Kennebac County Grand Jury meets again next week – the 19th to 21st. Once again, I am left hoping something comes of that but with each passing month, my hope diminishes.
Scout—
I don’t know how Maine works…does this HAVE to go to the Grand Jury? Or can the DA just file?
I would be very suprised if there were a court rule that allowed for an exception to a grand jury indictment in a case like this. Here is the statute:
§701. Criminal prosecutions by indictment; excepted cases
No person shall be held to answer in any court for an alleged offense, unless on an indictment found by a grand jury, except for contempt of court and in the following cases:
And here are the court rules that would list exceptions (I think exceptions are for lesser Class crimes than what kidnapping or homicide would fall under but I don’t have time to fully read)
http://www.courts.state.me.us/rules_adminorders/rules/mr_crim_p_only_9-2012.pdf
1. Use of charging instrument other than an indictment. When a prosecution utilizing a charging instrument other than an indictment is expressly authorized by rule of court; or
[ 1997, c. 4, §1 (RPR) .]
2. District Courts and courts martial. In proceedings before the District Court, the District Court acting as a juvenile court and courts martial.
My post is a bit out of order. The 1 and 2 exceptions at the bottom should be before the link to court rules for it to make sense. Bad copy and paste job into little comment box.
Thank you. I guess it’s possible to go forward w/o a grand jury but not likely. I wonder if the grand jury is the hold up?
Perhaps the DA thinks he/she has enough but the grand jury does not?
JW,
I was thinking the DA was the hold up. I wonder, could the Grand Jury indite but the DA hold off on an arrest to wait for more searches (body)? Or do they have to immediately act if the GJ indites?
It seems like the GJ indicting would signal to the DA that the case can move forward and head toward conviction.
I’m not sure though, hopefully a more knowledgeable person than myself will weigh in.
Couple things: Rules 7a and b say when a GJ indictment is not necessary. They are for lesser Class crimes (misdemeanors type crimes) and when a defendent waives indictment. I think Ayla’s case MUST come from a GJ indictment.
Secondly, an indictment can be sealed until all related arrests are made but I don’t think the DA (actually AG more likely in this case) can simply sit on the indictment for hope of finding more evidence. Or at least I don’t think they would. Why go to the GJ if you’re not willing to make an arrest and prosecute? You can still collect evidence after the indictment but there would be no reason to delay an arrest.
Thanks Scout. Very helpful. Only thing I can think of that would delay an arrest is the defendant’s right to a speedy trial. An arrest would start the clock, and the DA or AG may realize they still need lots of time?
I agree with Scout, Dee. IIRC it is the AG that prosecutes all murder cases in Maine. If there is an indictment, I do believe they can keep it sealed for an extended period for several reasons, new evidence comes to light, evidence is being retestested, interviews of new witnesses and examination of new tips I think could all be reasons to sit on the indictment if one is handed down.
I thank you also Scout. I am trying to understand the GJ process in ME and why if they’ve already heard this case once have there been no indictments? You make a good point with:
“Why go to the GJ if you’re not willing to make an arrest and prosecute? You can still collect evidence after the indictment but there would be no reason to delay an arrest.”
JW also makes a good point with:
“Only thing I can think of that would delay an arrest is the defendant’s right to a speedy trial. An arrest would start the clock, and the DA or AG may realize they still need lots of time?”
Thank you too John
Yes, justwondering, I think right to a speedy trial is an issue. A little googling and I found this article:
http://mainecrimes.com/memorandum-of-law-for-a-speedy-trial-violation/
Which in part says this:
“The length of delay is measured from the time of arrest, indictment, or information, whichever occurs first. Dillingham v. US, 423 US 64 (1975) and Barker v. Wingo, 407 US 514, 519-20 (1972). “
So then I think it would be somewhat safe to assume that the GJ has not indicted yet…
?
JW, no not really. There’s a possibility that they’ve indicted one person but believe there are other co-conspirators on whom they are building a case. McCausland made some comments about the magnitude of the investigation which could suggest there’s something bigger going on than has been released to the public.
Just Wondering, everyone here has made every attempt to be polite and respectful of you questions. The only attack was you calling Chicky and Myself liars for stating our opinions. If you continue to instigate controversy with your berating comments, I will be forced to respond in a fashion I do not chose to do lightly. Please sohow the same respect shown to you without the condescending and berating comments. TIA for your cooperation in this matter.
Thank you John, once again, for trying to keep the focus on Ayla.She deserves nothing less. This is her blog.
Johm P.
We must be reading this differently. I am asking questions to clarify, and the people who respond to be add in their own snark and loo.
Are you threatening to block me or what? Just come out and say it, I don’t need the sugarcoating….
Although blocking me, or reprimanding me, without saying anything to Suz or Chicky is kind of biased. I have not done anything that they didn’t.
Man up and tell them to focus on AYLA, AYLA, AYLA.
Thanks!
If you call me a liar again Justwondering, you will be placed in mandatory moderation. Suz and Chicky did not call you names when they disagreed with your assessment. You twisted thier words into something it was not. And so you know, the Ashley incident is what has brought about the process we will follow at U4A going forward. That process was included on the post and if you have not read the post but instead are just commenting to invoke discussion not related to Ayla then I will place you in moderation. You want me to man up, you start discussing Ayla related issues and stop instigating agruements or else. Is that manning up enough. Chicky and Suz were polite when commenting to you and now I will man up, with you. Keep it related to Ayla related issues and topics.
How is calling me racist having anything to do with Ayla? How is questioning my reading level being polite?
Please explain Johm P. because I think you’re being very unfair to me right now. Perhaps I should not have told you to man up, but come on!
I cannot be the only one who sees the unfairness in this situation.
Just to make things easier, CHICKY and SUZ better not respond to me any longer. I will stay in my corner and they can stay in their cages. The end. No interaction between me and them and all will be fine. If it happens, I am not responsible for the results.
Thanks for understanding Johm.
How is saying I have broken English polite??? When you say comments like that then I do question your reading level. I am guessing you went to school. Now about Ayla, has she had to chance to go to school? Or, to even be completely potty trained. I hope the kidnappers are changing her diapers and being nice to her. Justin seems to think the kidnappers are doing well by her.
Stop responding.
Trista doesnt plead to the kidnapper cause LE said there was No Kidnapping!!
John I take a little issue with this: you said everyone here has attempted to be polite; have you read Suz’s responses? Im not saying i agree either way, and I am not trying to stir the pot, but I don’t agree with that statement. Also, I would like to see where JW said, John you are a lair. Maybe I missed on another post? It just seems like you keep saying ‘call me a lair one more time..’. Maybe I’m missing entire threads or something?I know this has nothing to do with Ayla, and I am sorry for this post. I hate the drama too, I just felt I need to point out that clearly no everyone has attempted to be polite. Again, sorry for a non-Ayla post.
************And I have not been rude, but if someone lies then they are called a liar. It is a lie to say that Trista has pleaded for Ayla in every interview.
YOU look up the interviews and then come back and see how both you and Johm P. are now lying.**********
Gal, to answer your question.
Johm P. made a statement that wasn’t entirely true. Since I pointed that out, I am now in danger of being banned or blocked or whatever.
I’m supposed to take Johm P.’s word as fact,
even though I know it is not a fact, and he’s upset that someone has the audacity to question him.
That’s all that’s going on here. I have now posted
links to back up the facts—SO JOHM P. might need to apologize to me.
Just for the record, Trista has NOT pleaded for Ayla in every interview.
We are all entitled to our own opinions, but we cannot play fast and loose with the FACTS.
I stand by what I said. I’m speaking the truth, even though my voice might shake.
Gal higher on the page, this was posted,
Justwondering says:
September 13, 2012 at 12:58 am (Edit)
Nice, Chicky. What you believe is not fact. YOU look up the interviews and then come back and see how both you and Johm P. are now lying.
What is wrong with a little fact-checking? You are attacking me, but that is all I am doing. Balancing things is always a great thing when everyone in the world is out of control I always seek balance. I do yoga too.
Then this after I stated my comments were opinion and what I actually saw with my own two eyes,
And I have not been rude, but if someone lies then they are called a liar. It is a lie to say that Trista has pleaded for Ayla in every interview.
And all because I stated that Trista speaks on behalf of Ayla and attends events on behalf Ayla and I stated I saw her do just that Sept 1 at the Ride for Ayla. I don;t like getting upset Gal, it is not in my nature. But to me I have been called a liar for a statement I made that I witnessed and then the words twisted to mean something I did not say originally. It was very disturbing to me,
JW, reread my original comment before you called me a liar. This statement was added afterwards and now you are using this comment to continue calling me a liar. I am sorry but that is part of the rudeness I referred to. And yes calling us liars for stating our opinion as you want to be able to do is rude. You ask to be allowed to state your opinion, fine, allow us the same courtesy without calling us liars if you disagree. Thank you again now let’s move own, please.
John,
Take a few deep breaths and calm down please. I thought JW’s posts were ok. I think you’re taking it too personally and overreacting. There’s nothing wrong with questioning what we “think” we know. If we stand firm in one position without even considering anything else then that’s not truly looking for justice for Ayla. That’s just a witch hunt. One persons “fact” is anothers supposition.
People will argue on here, you’re not going to stop it no matter how hard you try unless you block everyone that disagrees with your stance. Chicky disagreed and respectfully declined to discuss it anymore. Suz on the other hand came off rude, as she often does.
I hope you take this in the manner it was intended and not as a bash on you.
I agree Dee. I have no problem taking a look at the other side or asking questions of any side. I do take objection however to being called a liar twice, for stating something I saw with my own two eyes.Thank you for the deep breathes I appreciate it. And I needed it. I do take it personnal sometimes when this type of namecalling is directed directly at me. Thanks for the calming words.
But it’s not rude and racist for someone to racial slurs against me and laugh about it?
What does this have to do with AYLA?
You need to reread my initial response. I SPECIFICALLY SAID A REVEIEW OF THE INTERVIEWS. Not a review of events or Johm P’s thoughts.
I give Trista, the mother of a missing, presumed deceased child, the up most respect and dignity. She needs no defending. I cannot even imagine how incredibly difficult this tragedy has been for her. It is unimaginable.
The person(s) responsible for harming Ayla and causing immense pain to her family will be brought to justice in due time.
Hugs for you today Trista.
Margy
ITA Margy…Hugs for you today Trista.
Good Morning! I tried to give Justwondering the benifit of the doubt and be open to an individual opinion but it became clear that the persons intent was to be disrespectfull and accusatory.
I apologise if my responding gave the opportunity or fuel for that person to continue on. I will in the future try to recognise earlier on when the conversation is only going to head further south.
As expected my post concerning justin and the media struck a nerve and there is a fairly short list of those who would respond in such a fashion.
Again my apologies for engaging in that conversation at all. The accusation of a crime or that I BOOKED an interview, that I am recieving compensation, that I am now a, “friend” to Justwondering or that I am a liar is nuts.
I take these kinds of confrontations with a grain of salt luckily so if the intention was to upset me or intimidate me the desired effect was not met.
Just Wondering calling me a “Ukrainian Mobster” was weird and uncalled for. Then saying I had broken English and using LOL on this blog was disrespectful. It’s exactly how Obscure talks to me, with out the STFU thrown in there and spelled completely out. I apologize for reacting a little bit. But, I stand by what I said. It is weird that Just Wondering is concerned and wants to guess about where my ancestors are from. They are not from Ukraine at all, but it’s a nice place to visit if you are adventurous. My Grandparents were born in Ireland and I am American born. Especially since I am a stranger and not related to Ayla. It seems racist and off topic to me. If I am bullied here or in JSTL I will not be scared off. I stand for true Justice for Ayla, and could care less about where in the world people are from.
Sounds like my neighbors from hell. ANYTHING to divert from the subject at hand which, in this case, is finding out what happened to AYLA. Justwondering is just stirring up trouble and John and Chicky are doing what I have done. Defend yourself and then get blamed and harassed. Also, “get dragged down the rabbit hole and wonder how you ever got there”. I say either block justwondering or just ignore this person and freeze this person out. God help me, but this back and forth is making me sick!
GAL… my post at 11:43 was for you in response to you saying *********
“Also, I would like to see where JW said, John you are a lair. Maybe I missed on another post?”
Any other posts from me, no, were not directed at you. Sorry for any confusion.
no worries, I can’t keep up. Thanks for reply. I’m not even sure now what post I was replying too or how it got all the way to the bottom.
I know, sometimes posts don’t show up where we think they will.
Chicky-huh? was the whole response directed towards me? I hope not; perhaps I am confused to your post. Either way, I am no longer responding to this issue. Sorry I commented on it in the first place.
A little bit of TRUTH goes a long way. This is the ACTUAL comment Johm P made, to which I responded and called him a liar (rightfully so IMO). No offense Johm.
Just Wondering. I respectfully disagree. Every interview she has done,she has begged for Ayla to return. Every event there is, Trista is there passing out posters, pins, pens, cards, hats, shirts, and talking to anyone that will talk with her. The latest event being Sept 1 in Portland, where she did do an interview, and where was the paternal family. I hope you understand why we dont talk about something that really does not exist in my eyes.
Reply
Justwondering says:
September 12, 2012 at 11:57 pm
Johm P—a simple review of Trista’s interviews proves your statement to be made up. That is simply not true.
Nothing against you, I would just hate for your inaccurate comment to become “fact” here in the blogoverse.
OBVIOUSLY, I’m responding to the part about the interviews. I have no idea how she acts at events. Maybe this is a misunderstanding? Idk but Johm, you have to get a grip.
Just wonedering. Once again and for the very last time. I am not going to argue this nonsense any longer. I am done with this topic COMPLETELY! Please move on to Ayla related topics. I hope this is the last time I have to respond to this nonsense.
Amen Johm, I can agree to that!
Everyone just calm down and trust the Lord!!!!!!!
JW – you almost made me pee my pants! lol
“Every event there is, Trista is there passing out posters, pins, pens, cards, hats, shirts, and talking to anyone that will talk with her”
Trista was not at the vigil Lance organized nor was she at the Eyes Open Walk for Baby Ayla in Waterville as I recall.
Just saying. People are blinded to the facts by their opinions and emotions and that doesn’t really help Ayla. It doesn’t help the credibility of this blog when simple fact-checking returns that statements made as fact are shown to be untruths.
Thanks again Scout. I did ask however that we move on from this topic. I said it before to your observation that I was wrong in commenting when I was so frustrated. I have asked that we move on from this issue. If you want to point out each of my mistakes we are going to be in for a very long night.
I am not trying to be sarcastic, I am admitting I have made mistakes in the past. If this is about JW being in moderation, I need to know why am I running into so much resistance in trying to fix this mistake? Why can’t we just move past the JW issue and talk about finding Ayla. I asked previously if there was anyone who disagreed with my decision concerning JW, they were welcome to e-mail me but I preferred to keep it off the blog.
If you are simply trying to point out another of my many mistakes, I agree I was wrong. I spoke in frustration. My apologies
Let me repeat it for you, John.
People are blinded to the facts by their opinions and emotions and that doesn’t really help Ayla. It doesn’t help the credibility of this blog when simple fact-checking returns that statements made as fact are shown to be untruths.
You’re in deep. You’ve had moderation and administration of this blog left to you from all appearances. You’re also #1 commenter here. You’re deeply invested in this case for whatever reason and are sacrificing your emotional and physical health in the process. If you are okay with taking on such a burden you have to be willing to take the tough questions and the solid observations with it. If that means ruling with an iron fist you get to deal with the push back you’ll get for censoring sincere posts. It’s a tough spot to be in John and I don’t have the answer for you but I will tell you that I think you are being used in a most unfair way by the owners of this blog.
Scout you could email John privately and discuss your concerns with him.
I got it the first time that people are blinded by emotions and opinions. That is why I stated twice that my frustrations got in the way and I was wrong. That is the most I can do.
As for your comments on my position on the blog, you say “You’re deeply invested in this case for whatever reason and are sacrificing your emotional and physical health in the process.” I say that everyone here understands why I am willing to take on so much and sacrifice my health. It is and has been for Ayla. Do I enjoy being the target of the name calling and the personal attacks, hell no. Do I prefer they be against me, yup! The problem Scout, is we have been trying to move past it and it is being brought up all over again. I asked 4 times for JW to move on and the third time I was called a liar was my limit of tolerance. Regardless of what you think of me, I can only withstand so much before I “man up” as JW told me to.
Once again, you have made your point on this topic, you have proven you are right, I have admitted my mistake and apologized , I have my emotions under control finally and I am no longer seeing red. With all of that said, can you please move on to another topic. I do not want this to lead to another arguement about my mistakes instead of disussing Ayla. I still would prefer if you want to discuss this further, as I have politely asked twice before, please keep it off the blog and e-mail me. I will listen to you point out every mistake I have made but this blog is for Ayla.
Stop calling me by ethnic slurs and laughing about it. The fact is that is a racist action. I am not ” calling” you anything, “Just Wondering”
I made an ANALOGY, I didn’t call you anything.
I said LIKE a Ukranian Mobster. I was watching I married a Mobster at that time. lol
I 100% support John in his efforts to keep this blog about Ayla. I support whatever he needs to do to keep the focus on her as this is Ayla’s blog.
Seems best not to reply to posts that are intended to stir up the pot which puts Ayla out of the number one spot on her own blog. JMO
AMEN to that girlfriend!
Thank you Margy, back to Ayla.
Agreed, I almost responded to one glad I read this first.
John, perhaps if the denigrating conversations or remarks are removed then we can get back to a civilized conversation and or speculation. If the comments are removed no one has to look at them or respond to or comment on them. The thread is about LE statements, let’s get back to that.
Amen, No One Special! ITA! How about starting with the aspersions cast against McKee for simply asking if Jeff was at the Ride for Ayla?:
http://united4ayla.com/comments-and-pictures-from-a-ride-for-ayla/#comment-30288
I would like to No One Special. If I do I will be cast afire for censoring. If I leave it it perpetuates the conversation. There is no winning with this problem except to ask all to move on and leave the topic to fade away. Just my take on the situation but it is a lose lose unless we just move on.
John, I personally don’t have any problems with a moderator censoring inappropriate content, but I do think it should be done across the board as opposed to selectively allowing certain people to break the rules you’ve set. When that happens it looks like favoritism and a biased blog.
Why are people permitted to bash kitty and others who simply ask questions?
John, you’re doing a great job! You’ve been fair to Everyone!
Team?Truth?@12:49
FYI kitty and today’s culprit have done more than ask ?s. They do it in a way that is very critical of other bloggers OR u4a admins. I am not responding to start a fight: I WILL NOT PARTICIPATE, but just to explain why the way in which someone participates, is reflected in how their “opinions” are received!
I agree ladybug.
I also agree, ldybg.
ITA also Ldybg. Thank you for explaining it in a way I could not.
Hi Mathilda there was no place to reply earlier, good to see you too. Chicky and Ladybug, you’re locals, how far from Waterville was the search that Ruby posted about?
Mama, was that Fairfield ? If so that is right next door to waterville as far as I know.
Mama, it is right next door, North of waterville and the Kennebec runs right through it.
I understand your position John and it is not an enviable one. Just continue to fight the good fight and continue on. Most of us are stating our comments and opinions based on the facts as we know them. No one outside of LE is privy to the inner workings of this case.
Thank you Heartbroken and No One Special. I will try to be quicker next time. There is only so much that I can do on a 15 minute break from work. I do appreciate both of your continued support for Ayla.
John, you are doing a wonderfull job!
Thank you Chicky. I appreciate your patience and trying to be nice. I know it was hard with what was being said and the accusations being made.
You are welcome John. Like I said, I took it with a grain of salt and for what it is.
You are lying, you think you are really smart. You saw something personal about me that ended up on a Facebook page “Justice for “Ayla” and you ran with it. I have since deleted that info. It showed up there by accident, when it was meant for a private message.
Suzanne Cotter Oh my God! That was a private message to my daughter in the Ukraine. She is 9 months pregnant in the hospital with a heart condition. I am so sorry Amy-Beth Doyon I had a friend write that for me so I don’t know how it ended up here. I am on my phone right now. I am going to try to delete it from here and paste it to a private message. Thanks for letting me know. Any news on Ayla?
17 hours ago via mobile · Like · 1
Justwondering says:
September 13, 2012 at 12:11 pm
I made an ANALOGY, I didn’t call you anything.
I said LIKE a Ukranian Mobster. I was watching I married a Mobster at that time. lol
Reply
What does this have to do with AYLA?
Is AYLA in the Ukraine?
Exactly my point, why DID you bring it up Just Wondrring? What was your motive?? To divert this blog away from Ayla and to bash me IMO.
What does this have to do with AYLA?
Did AYLA bring this up?
Arghhhhh!!! Make it stop!
Please stop engaging Suz JW.
No,you brought it up Just Wondering. Did you want to talk about it? If not why did you bring it up in a page for Ayla?
John P says:
September 13, 2012 at 12:43 pm
I would like to No One Special. If I do I will be cast afire for censoring. If I leave it it perpetuates the conversation. There is no winning with this problem except to ask all to move on and leave the topic to fade away. Just my take on the situation but it is a lose lose unless we just move on.
—————————————————
Good Afternoon
John, my friend, you have done all that you can do, its beyond censorship now.
As with children, you stated the terms, when those terms are broken, you follow through. jmo
I totally agree Anon. Nice to hear from you. I firmly believe that some folks are not going to just move on. So whatever it takes to, once again, put Ayla back in the #1 place on her own blog.
Prayers for this sweet little girl.
Amen LE Anon.
Thank you LE Anon. I agree with your assessment. I hope that everyone can now get back to Ayla and topics concerning Ayla. I thank you for theadvice my friend. It was and is the correct advice as well.
To everyone, please leave the previous comment by JustWondering in the past where they belong. I will moderate all additional comments from that IP and if appropriate I will approve otherwise I will not. I hate doing this to anyone on Aylas blog but the rules have been stated and I will follow through with them.
margyf1 says:
September 13, 2012 at 1:53 pm
I totally agree Anon. Nice to hear from you. I firmly believe that some folks are not going to just move on. So whatever it takes to, once again, put Ayla back in the #1 place on her own blog.
Prayers for this sweet little girl.
——————-
Hello margyf1 – Thank you for the greeting. The juvenile antics are just that, juvenile. The few are having a great time disrupting this blog, pushing the limits, waiting for their punishment (deleted or banned) so they can go to their “Home Blog” & have something to talk about.
-
I for one, say good bye! – jmo
Thanks Anon:
I very much agree with you: I say good bye as well to those who disrupt the focus on Ayla. Enough is enough. John certainly has done more than he could do.
mountain mama says:
September 13, 2012 at 2:08 pm
Amen LE Anon.
———————
mm – Its nice to see you!
It’s great to see you LE Anon! That’s one fine grandson you’ve got! I would’ve been here sooner but it took a while to get my armor on
I’m trying to be patient like you said but I soooo wish charges would be filed and Ayla’s justice was a little closer.
I agree Mama, LEannons grandson seems like a special person!
LE Anon, Maybe you can address the grand jury questions some were asking. In short,
1. what is the likelihood of an indictment having been handed down and sealed
2. is there an actual limit on how long a prosecutor can hold an indictment that is not sealed pre-arrest
3. if no limit, what are the normal practices in Maine?
Yes please. We actually had a decent conversation going about this topic.
Info on the Grand Jury is very interesting, this is an area I really know nothing about.
I do believe we’ve reached the point of Argumentum ad nauseam on a couple of threads. Time to get back to discussing the case. LE Anon, I’d like to add an additional question to CG’s post. Given the high profile of this case, especially in and around the Kennebec County area, is it possible this case will be tried or moved to another jurisdiction.
mountain mama says:
September 13, 2012 at 2:30 pm
It’s great to see you LE Anon! That’s one fine grandson you’ve got! I would’ve been here sooner but it took a while to get my armor on I’m trying to be patient like you said but I soooo wish charges would be filed and Ayla’s justice was a little closer.
———————
Thank you for your compliment regarding my grandson, it means alot.
Theres no need for armor here (just ignore).
-
Ayla will have her justice, be patient my friend. I know I sound like a broken record & the fact that similar cases have no resolution to date makes it even harder to believe; but there is alot of evidence in this case & I strongly believe an arrest will be made & Ayla will get justice!
It’s allways nice to hear a strong voice of reason saying that justice will be served. It sort of feels like when you are a child and your Mother says, “Don’t’ worry, everything will be allright”
Thank you
“Ayla will have her justice, be patient my friend. I know I sound like a broken record & the fact that similar cases have no resolution to date makes it even harder to believe; but there is alot of evidence in this case & I strongly believe an arrest will be made & Ayla will get justice!”
Thank you Anon. It’s nice to hear there is a lot of evidence in this case.
Question: Do you think LE will have to find Ayla first before any arrests are made?
I wonder how much time LE will allow for finding her?
CG says:
September 13, 2012 at 2:25 pm
LE Anon, Maybe you can address the grand jury questions some were asking. In short,
1. what is the likelihood of an indictment having been handed down and sealed
2. is there an actual limit on how long a prosecutor can hold an indictment that is not sealed pre-arrest
3. if no limit, what are the normal practices in Maine?
———————-
1. Its possible; but I doubt it. (my opinon only)
2. I will answer # 2& 3 together – I don’t know the laws of Maine, sorry.
I went looking for answers to the Grand Jury questions myself and a few others were talking about yesterday. I pulled this off a site called wisegeek.com.
A secret indictment is an indictment that is not made public until the subject of the indictment has been arrested, notified, or released pending trial. Secret indictments are primarily seen in the United States, because they are issued by grand juries
and most other countries do not use the grand jury in their justice system. In America, a grand jury hears the key facts of a case to decide if there is enough evidence for someone to stand trial. If they believe that a trial is warranted, they issue an indictment, a formal accusation which serves as a warning to the accused that a trial will be held.
Sometimes, it is determined that the indictment should be kept secret. A secret indictment may also be known as a sealed indictment or silent indictment. In this case, the documentation surrounding the indictment is kept under seal,
and no one involved may discuss the indictment outside of the grand jury hearings, or with anyone else once the hearings are over. When the seal is lifted, the contents of the indictment can be made public.
Prosecutors may request a secret indictment if they are concerned that someone may flee if they become aware that trial proceedings against them are being set in motion. It is also possible to ask for a secret indictment to protect witnesses and
other people involved with the case. If a suspected criminal is aware that grand jury hearings are occurring, the criminal may take steps to interfere with the hearings, such as intimidating witnesses or members of the grand jury. By sealing the
indictment, the prosecutor ensures that the process will be safe for everyone.
Secret indictments are perfectly legal. They do not infringe upon the rights of the accused, including the right to a trial by jury and the right to hear evidence and cross-examine witnesses. Some people criticize the sealed indictment process
because they argue that it is abused and that the information should be on the public record, but the justifications for the process far outweigh these concerns.
The indictment will be unsealed when the government feels that it is appropriate to do so. As long as someone remains at large, the indictment typically remains sealed, because the case is considered active. People who have evaded arrest must usually surrender to law enforcement before they can determine the contents of a secret indictment, and it is advisable to surrender with the assistance of a lawyer.
So in reading this explanation, my opinion is it probably won’t be a sealed indictment if and when one happens to be handed down. Would there be a point? JD would obviously already know about GJ proceedings if his mother, sister and girlfriend were allegedly already called to testify in them (which tells me he was the focus of the proceeding since he wasn’t called). They’re not supposed to discuss what was said or asked (but they probably would, they’re family) but he’d at least know about it. The only reason that I can think of at this point to cause it to be sealed is if there was a witness to something and they don’t want that witness to be known.
Opinion?
Thanks for the info Dee. I agree with you that the only reason it would be sealed is if it would protect a witness. (Non family member) It has been my hope all along that they do have a witness.
Thank you for the information, Dee. Do you recall if Courtney’s sister was arrested before or after the grand jury proceedings?
idk mathilda, sorry.
I found a case in Maine that dealt with drugs and a shooting. And the individual was arrested on a sealed indictment for multiple charges MONTHS later than when the incident occured. Incident occured in February 2012 and individual was arrested in June 2012. Case was nothing like Ayla but just an example of length of process for sealed indictments.
Thanks Dee. It has been my HOPE all along that the reason for the concentrated and continued searches in the Waterville area and in this waters around that area, was because of a witness that must be kept confidential.
No One Special says:
September 13, 2012 at 2:42 pm
I do believe we’ve reached the point of Argumentum ad nauseam on a couple of threads. Time to get back to discussing the case. LE Anon, I’d like to add an additional question to CG’s post. Given the high profile of this case, especially in and around the Kennebec County area, is it possible this case will be tried or moved to another jurisdiction.
—————
In my opinon, Yes
Thank you LE.
Chicky says:
September 13, 2012 at 2:52 pm
I agree Mama, LEannons grandson seems like a special person!
——————-
Hi Chicky! – Thank you, I really appreciate the compliment!
9/4/2012
WEEKLY REPORT MAJOR CRIMES UNIT – NORTH August 27, 2012 to September 2, 2012
I. Items of interest to Local Media:
Det. Brockway continued working on reports in regards to the China Homicide and other sex cases.
Det. Brockway attended a Forensic Interviewers peer review meeting in Hallowell.
Det. Chabot participated in a K9 search in Fairfield in reference to the Ayla Reynolds missing person’s case.
Just saw the above post for September 4th for a search that was not publicized for Ayla. If you go to the MSP web site they give updates for the North and South divisions of the Major Crimes Unit. I sent this because some people worry that this is going to be a cold case. But it appears that MSP is doing what they said (more searches…not announced. And they will not let the case run cold. This is encouraging news for me.
Thanks Ruby. Ayla’s case will not become a cold case.
Mama: I have to reply here (grrrr) because the option wasn’t avail above. Fairfield, is, as john & chicky already stated, on the northern boundary of Waterville.
Great catch, Ruby! A K9 search? Oooh! I’ve often thought about the woods of Fairfield, as well as the areas of the Kennebec and I95 that run through it, as being a likely place for a search…hopes and prayers that LE will catch a break!
Ldybg:
Do you know if Fairfield was a place where Justin spent time?
Justin was taking his CDL at the Lawrence public school complex which is located in Fairfield.
Sorry Ladybug I just saw this. I’m hoping and praying that LE already has caught that break.
Good find Ruby. It is heartening to know they’re searching even if they’re not saying anything about it.
Yes, good find Ruby, thank you for sharing!
Thank you so very much Ruby for posting this. This is fantastic news.
Let’s find Ayla and bring her home.
Mountain Mama. Fairfield is a town that borders Waterville. Fairfield is also the town that Justin was taking his trucking courses.
Thank you Ruby. I knew I had heard that city before but could not place it until you mentioned the CDL course. That is where I remembered hearing it from.
Its time for me to go, I wish I had more time with all of you; but I have obligations to tend to.
-
If I may say, keep Ayla first & foremost, thats why were here.
John my friend, your doing an excellent job!
Thank You for your comments and answers. Take care of yourself and all my best to you. <3 ms.peridot19
I agree MsP. Anon take care of yourself and we will see you soon.
And MsP, welcome back. It has been so long since I have seen you. I hope you too are well and again, it is great seeing you back.
This will probably be my last comment here. I have made a bad choice in trying to fisg for info over at jstl. they decided to disclose my emails because i wrote about Elisha. I felt it to be a very serious issue that My family hadn’t heard from the family about Gabby in over a month and that they all seemed to moved. I am wrong for writing a post that didn’t have anything to do with Ayla. i’m sorry to everyone who i’ve disapointed. But I can’t help the way my mind works and the way I go about the things i want to do so with that I leave U4A I would like my posts removed and thats it. Thank you.
I understand Ashley. As the old saying goes, once a snake always a snake (JSTL). You got bitten, and you have apologized . Take care of yourself, and thank you for fighting for Ayla, and Ayla’s first cousin.
I agree with Suz! Ashley, I’m sure you’re not the only one that has tried that n I wouldn’t be surprised if there is some still in progress. It just shows how far you’re willing to go for sweet baby Ayla.
Ashley, I agree with Suz and Heartbroken. It is hard to make a mistake and then admit to it. I do not feel the posts were the issue for me, as i do agree a childs welfare is very important and must be found above all else. For me personally it was the e-mail disclosure by JSTL that I had the issue with. You have apologized and I believe your explanation, for whatever my beliefs are worth or not. I encourage you to continue to comment for Ayla, though I do not agree with the e-mails you sent to the other blog, you have apologized and have had Aylas best interest in heart. Thank you for listening.
If they are going to post private emails then they should be fair and post both sides of the conversation .
This is why we do not post emails Sara. It is impossible to say what was said before, after, or in reply to any e-mail they posted regarding Ashley.
Thank you Ashley and looking forward to your continued posts.
Ashley is this really your post over at JSTL?
Ashley9/13/12 2:41 PM
You all have no idea what I think or feel ecspecially when it comes to Ayla! I have been on both sides of this and I do feel there is something going on with the Reynolds side of things here. I know there is a reason why Tori left U4A and that she is definetley not going to be back there. I am wrong for talking about ELisha and JLs custody situation yes i agree there it was not meant to be talked about but JL is related to me and he does deserve to see his daughter. He is not an animal as many of you all think and neither am I. I just want Ayla to be brought back from who ever has her. Do I think she is dead heck No! and Do I think that she was hurt by the Dipietro’s no I truely do not. As of now I just as well as all of you haven’t the slightest clue what happened to Ayla.I am just here to read theories and thoughts on what may have happened to her. I know I look like a snake in the grass but i am just curious to all of the possibilities.
I hope John obliges and removes your posts about Elisha and Justin Linnell.
I am quite confused about why some feel the Elisha/ JL posts should be removed. IMO they were put here to, and actually do reflect rather genuinely on Elisha’s personality or at least her typical M.O. She is, as well as can be determined, one of the 3 adults present in the home on the night that Ayla was hurt or killed! I do not have a problem with Ashley opening a discussion on Aylas aunt/ cousin and I certainly do not see it as something to make a BIG fuss over. jmo…
Once again Lady bug I agree with you.
Ldybg. I temporarily removed them as requested by Ashley. I have not deleted them because there many good comments. There are also many negative comments about commentators as well. I want to keep the good and delete the bad, but it is either all or nothing. I will leave it up to Ashley since she is the one who asked me to remove them. Obviously they have been copy pasted all over the internet so they are not completely gone. But I will honor the request as it stands.
I understand, john! What can u do?! :/
To everyone, please leave the previous comments by JustWondering in the past where they belong. It is far too big a distraction from Ayla. I will moderate all additional comments from that IP and user, and if appropriate I will approve otherwise I will not. I hate doing this to anyone on Aylas blog but the rules have been stated and I will follow through with them. If you disagree with moderation for JW please e-mail me directly, and leave them off Aylas blog. I will address each e-mail when I get to them. I already have over 50 to sort through so I will be a while in getting back to you. I do apologize to the great people at U4A for having to deal with this distraction.
To those who were offended by JW, I ask that you please also help me in this matter by no longer commenting as JW can no longer reply without moderation. I also ask that if you comment about JW or McKee, please do so politely and without the name calling so I may move the discussions back to where they belong which is pertaining to topics related to Ayla. TIA and again, I do apologize for taking so long to get home from work to handle this matter.
Thank you all for understanding and I will continue to be open and post comments here at u4a I also have other things to do on my facebook pages to keep Ayla in the limelight.
thank you again,
Ashley
heartbroken says:
September 13, 2012 at 5:48 pm
Trista doesnt plead to the kidnapper cause LE said there was No Kidnapping!!
EXACTLY and well said hb! As you know, and I’m sure those previously questioning Trista speaking out for Ayla also know, although she hasnt pleaded to a kidnapper, she HAS pleaded to Justin! She has begged and pleaded for him to communicate with her and stop WITHHOLDING information about Ayla’s disappearance.
The MSP are saying the SAME thing to JD and CO! (go figure)
Well said ladybug.
I will be gone for for two or three days so won’t be chiming in. I hope this is a pleasant weekend here and that respect abounds. One of the simplest things we can do for Ayla and that sweet little girl deserves so much more.
Absolutely Chicky!
You stay safe and enjoy your mini vacation Chicky. Thank you for letting every one know so do not worry when you do not comment for a few. I do hope you have a pleasant weekend also.
Thank you John, I will, I am looking forward to it !
Thank you, chicky! A pleasant weekend it is supposed to be and hope you enjoy it entirely!
Thank you Ladybug! yes, I have checked the extended forcast and it looks like nice weather altho it may be chilly in the mornings. There is a little woodstove, toasted marshmellow for breakfast ?
Oh, man! I wont tell my 4 and 7 yr olds- they’d be there to make S’mores- for breakfast???? Lmbo
Yup, two old ladies sitting by the wood stove toasting marshmellow on a cool morning in Maine while hearing the sounds of seagulls and the sight of a sailboat sailing by.
Ldybg, now I am mad at you and chicky. It is going on 11 at night and now I have a craving for smores!!!
I’ll accept the blame for that one John !
I’m a proud granmother of 3 but I am still a kid at heart and enjoy those simple pleasures in life.
God bless you all! You are really the best!
same here chicky, I have 3 grandkids as well. Nothing like being a nana. Enjoy your vacation.
I hope you’re all happy! Mr M and I are about to have some chocolate ice cream. Not to worry, I removed all the calories with my magic wand.
Thank you Heartbroken, and yes, being a Grammy is simply wonderfull!
Proud Pepere of three here. Craving smores and ice cream now. I need that wand so I can grub before bed. Oh well, as I said, time for prayers and bed. Thank you all for continuing to support Ayla so strongly.
Night Grampa!
Yes enjoy your weekend Chicky. Umm I got lost but I wanted to thank Chicky and Ruby for explaining where Fairfield is. So they were that close and no one knew about it. I wonder just how many searches have been done that we don’t know about. I so hope Ayla is found.
I have forgotten what i read concerning the search but was it a river search or ground? I do hope they are doing many searches. If they are doing ground searches I really wish that they would utilize the public more as grid searches are more effective with a larger number of people.
Thank you Mama I will enjoy the weekend. There is a beautifull view of a lovely cove from the screened in porch at camp, very calming and I have a wonderfull sister to enjoy it with this weekend!
Sounds calm and relaxing Chicky, the older we get the more special our sisters are to us.
I believe it was a ground search since they used a K-9. Don’t know for sure. Maybe they were checking up on some very specific lead or tip. And that’s why they didn’t utilize more people for a grid search.
Sorry but, does K-9 include ( water) cadaver dogs ? So difficult to make any referance to anything other than a healthy child.
Yes, K-9 includes water. They are specially trained to find remains in water as well
as land. These dogs are amazing. Very impressive.
To add to my comment on K-9 dogs:
There are K-9 dogs trained for search and rescue and other
K-9 dogs specially trained to find just remains. So 2 different types.
Just wanted to clear that up.
These unannounced searches give me hope that like you said Ruby, tips may still be coming in. Good tips.
True~ chicky. I just keep telling myself “…you cant change what someone did to Ayla- but you CAN help find justice for Ayla, other babies/children, and closure for a grieving mother!
Ladybug, now see what you have done, teary eyes. I cannot imagin how trista is suffering and morso cannot imagin what Ayla has been through.
Sad, oooo so sad.
Since I am getting choked up, I think I will sign off and say my prayers for Ayla and Family. May they find answers, may justice follow soon, and may Ayla be brought home even sooner! we miss you buggie, we want you home.
Good night John.
Amen John. I’d like to believe that arrests are coming soon especially
after what Anon LE said that they have a lot of evidence in this
case.
I’m glad we know that MSP are still actively searching for Ayla.
The waiting still is hard….just have to hang in there.
For those who harmed Ayla: Only a matter of time before you
get that dreaded knock on your door!
Amen Ldybg.
All mothers of missing children are going through a horrible ordeal. I can’t imagine dealing with it…to rob a child of it’s whole life practically should be punishable with life in prison without parole.
I wholeheartedly agree, margyf1. We have that situation here in Oregon with Kyron Horman’s disappearance. Terri Horman, (his stepmother), has still not been arrested more than two years later. Kyron’s Momma, Desiree, has really put Kyron back in the news lately with the civil suit she filed against Terri Horman. Kyron’s story will be featured on America’s Most Wanted tonight. Please, everyone if you can watch it. Although the statistical chances of Kyron being alive somewhere are very slim, there is always a chance albeit small. Just as in Ayla’s case, all it takes is one good tip to break this case wide open. As a busy mother of four children, I can only focus on and keep up with Kyron’s and Ayla’s cases. But, I am determined to be a voice for both of these beautiful children until justice is reached. I am confident that the MSP will make arrests and there will be justice for Ayla and her family.
There’s still a 1 % chance girls.
I will take that every day of the week Mama. Come home soon Ayla, we miss you immensley!
This is true Mama.
Nite all. Praying you’ll be found tomorrow Ayla Bell.
Night Mama. Ayla Bell, such a pretty name. One day, and it can’t be soon enough, she will be found and justice will be served to those who have caused her pain.
Ayla’s grandmother, Phoebe DiPietro, also wouldn’t discuss the discovery.
“Personally, I do not believe anything happened to Ayla other than she was taken,” she said.
To her Ayla was just taken, no big deal. She was taken that’s all. No concern for Ayla or her well being.
This is sorta OT but Sky Metawala’s case has some similarities to Ayla’s case. Sky went missing during a custody battle and his mom, the last one to see him won’t cooperate with LE, neither will her family and friends. Sky’s father has set up vigils and used the media to plead for Sky’s return or information that would lead to his return. Sky, 2 years old, has been missing since November. Even though Sky hasn’t been found the custody issue still went through the courts, and Sky’s father was awarded legal custody. I know this has been brought up before, but I don’t remember what the answer was, why hasn’t Ayla’s custody issue gone through the court by now? If there’s still a 1 % chance Ayla is alive, shouldn’t someone be awarded legal custody in the possibilty that Ayla IS found alive?
Also, Sky’s father and his attorney want to release information from the investigation but LE says it could jeapordize the investigation. So to those who don’t believe LE would share info with Trista that they haven’t shared with the public, you might want to read Sky’s story.
What distinguishes Sky’s and Amir’s cases in my mind is parental mental illness. When a person suffers a psychotic disorder (can’t remember what Julia had but Zinah has schizophrenia) asking for cooperation is trying to superimpose reason onto an illness that by nature interferes with reason. Justin’s failure to cooperate (if police correct) is not the product of any psychotic process or reaction to one.
I agree CG, but in Amir’s case Zina’s family and friends cooperated with LE, and in Sky’s case Julia’s family and friends have refused to cooperate.
Another eerie similarity is the way other children were present or in the area when the little child disappear. At least with Sky, I am not sure about Amir’s case. But with Sky, the mother parked on the street and took the older sister to go for gas leaving Amir in the car alone. With Justin and Courtney, they had Ayden in the basement with them, even though Justin feared Ayla being taken from him. To big a coincidence for me.
John: “With Justin and Courtney, they had Ayden in the basement with them, even though Justin feared Ayla being taken from him. To big a coincidence
for me.”
Another big Red Flag. Ayla wasn’t even sleeping on the same floor
If Justin was so worried of abduction why did he want Ayla upstairs.
Out of his sight. Oh yeah that’s because he really did not give a hoot
about Ayla….forgot..This guy is truly a piece of work.
MSP just needs a little more evidence and then Bingo, they will
make their arrests. IMO
Just Wondering what happened to Ayla and Lisa Irwin and Isabel Celis and Kyron Horman and all the other little people. I vote to allow the use of sodium pentothal in cases of missing children.
LL ITA. Whatever it takes. These people might have thought twice before harming these children if they knew they would be forced to talk. Unfortunately, child murderers have the same rights as everyone else, and I don’t see how that can be changed.
In the Amir Jennings case, the prosecutor was able to win on a claim of child abandonment when the mom couldn’t account for her son’s whereabouts. In most cases, I think that would be a tough and dangerous path, though. Sometimes kids are really kidnapped out of their beds and police don’t believe it. Rare, but it happens. Putting someone in jail when they can’t account for their kid’s whereabouts in probably most cases would be misguided. Prosecuting on subsidiary or incidental, not necessarily related crimes is a tack prosecutors more often use effectively like Haleigh Cummings or the initial approach not followed through on with Jahessye Shockley.
Again I agree CG. There’s no way to protect the truly innocent whose rights would be lost along with the truly guilty.
They put the tot mom, Casey Anthony, in jail when she couldn’t account for the disappearance of Caylee. Does anyone recall the initial charge which landed her in jail? I think it was lying to police. Does anyone have that first charge on their mental radar? Later, she was charged with murder, but at first, it was something
less than murder.
I can’t remember Penny but I do remember when they charged Elisa Baker with obstruction of justice and eventually she was convicted of murdering Zahra Baker, her stepdaughter.
http://media.trb.com/media/acrobat/2008-08/41377
872.pdf Casey Anthony arrest report
Yes, mountain mama. Remember in the Zahra Baker case, Elisa told law enforcement where Zahra’s remains were AFTER being arrested. I wish that law enforcement would do something similar to Courtney Reynolds or Elisha DiPietro to get them to talk.
No, she was jailed for writing bad checks. Completely unrelated.
Sorry, I am getting confused. I gather that there was a Grand Jury Hearing and P., E., and C. and maybe L. were summoned. When did this take place? Did they say there was enough for an arrest which I think is a “true bill”? What does LE have to say to the maternal family? Seems that so much is going in different directions. I would appreciate any answers to the above questions. My head is spinning and I have 2 patients to take care of, my husband and my 81 year old girl friend who fell and broke her scapula so guess who is doing corpreal works of mercy big time. Neither one can drive and I am exhausted.
Feb 9. No one knows what happened because of grand jury secrecy but there has been no true bill announced.
Sorry to hear of your personal circumstances- that;s a tough situation.
Thanks for the answers and the sympathies. I think I am racking up a lot a grace for my soul. Not a bad thing.
Poor Trista, things are moving SO slowly and STILL no Ayla and no answers. I stopped by Joan’s Grotto and prayed for Ayla to come home along with other personal requests that I have. I know everything is in God’s time, but damn, we are living, eating, sleeping and breathing this non stop.
“I know everything is in God’s time, but damn, we are living, eating, sleeping and breathing this non stop.”
You can say that again ginas. I think of Ayla all the time. We just have to
keep the faith that MSP will get those responsible for this
tragedy soon and they will be punished for what they did to Ayla.
Thank you CG, Ginas & Margy. ITA that God will find a way to ensure Ayla has Answers and Justice. He does know best. But I too wish we could get a sign soon.
I am working on the next LE Statements post BY Purple And hope to have it up tonigh before we go to bed. I know we are over 300 comments and I am working as fast as I can to get a new page up. Sorry to those on personal mobile devices/
John will you still be putting up PB’s LE Statements post?
Sorry Mama, I forgot to hit the last button to publish it. The post is now up.
I think the grand jury was sometime in the early spring. Please correct me if I am wrong.
I find it odd that some people are gullible enough to believe Justin and co. that Ayla was kidnapped. Even LE has stated that Ayla wasn’t kidnapped and that they don’t believe that Ayla will be coming home alive. They have searched rivers and other water ways for Ayla, which with those searches should be enough evidence for the public eye…that Ayla is indeed gone.
LE doesn’t search water for the hell of it.
I hope that they find Ayla before the 1 year mark. I wish whoever knows the truth..would just step forward and sing like a canary.
They need to put themselves in Trista’s shoes or take a step back to think about how they would feel..if they were in a situation where their child went missing or had been possibly murdered.
If someone just comes forward with the truth…they will most likely get a lighter sentences than everyone else. People who withhold information get time tacked on. I know someone who once was an accomplice of murder and since he narked…he only got 8 years in prison. 8 years isn’t so bad for being a nark. My cousin received 13 or 14 years in jail just for sale/possession of drugs and for robbery.
Just some food for thought…
I think you’re right. The one who rolls on the others usually gets the best deal. Hopefully, the one who rolls is the least culpable to begin with.
Let the rolling begin!
I think you are right Slotsky. IIRC, the GJ was in Feb some time. Not sure exactly when in Feb. I would look it up but my mind is not clear right now. Getting late and will be calling it a night soon.
Feb 9. Given the need to get the subpoenas out with proper notice, this means investigators knew fairly early on where this case was headed. Probably before Bill Stokes was brought in to see the crime scene. http://www.wmtw.com/Crime-Scene-Tape-Placed-Around-Home-Of-Ayla-Reynolds/-/8792672/9570032/-/e5kw0qz/-/index.html
Thanks for verifying the date CG. The one question I have is that I agree that LE knew where the case was heading on the 22nd when Mr. Stokes was brought in, I do not think they subpeonas whould have been requested by then. I was thinking that the house processing and forensic results would have started coming in befor ethe request for subpoenas, somewhere in early Jan. What are your thoughts?
I suspect subpoenas were issued on 30 days notice but didn’t look it up; however, a prosecutor has to prepare to go to the grand jury and would have to know who he was subpoenaing and why and get the subpoenas ready before the issuance date
If you look at when Phoebe and Elisha hired at a lawyer- early January- it adds to the impression that’s when the subpoenas went out
The early Jan time frame makes alot of sense CG. I think maybe I misunderstood your original comment. I can’t find it now due to the # of comments on the page, but I thought that you were saying that when they knew where the investigation was heading,the new who the subpoenas were going to be issued to as well. I appreciate the clarification for me.
Day 6:
2 homicide prosecutors brought in
investigation focused closely on 29 Violette
cadaver dogs searching near airport
but the police were also keeping open the possibility she was alive with 50 SAR and 75-80 LE officers conducting searches http://www.foxnews.com/us/2011/12/22/crime-scene-tape-around-home-missing-maine-toddler/
Acc. to City-Data, Waterville had 41 F/T LE personnel as of 2010. Unless its force increased dramatically by the time Ayla was reported missing, it was expending incredible effort and using lots of outside resources
Major Crimes Unit took over case Dec. 30/ that was the same day the foul play finding was announced/ Major Crimes investigates homicides, suspicious deaths and other major investigations http://www.kjonline.com/news/special-unit-investigates-ayla-reynolds-disappearance_2012-01-04.html